Friday, January 15, 2016

Public Concern: Courts Should Interfere

Whether Courts Should Interfere in Matters Involving Regulation of Genetically Modified Foods

What is Genetically Modified Foods?

According to the World Health Organization (WHO), "Genetically Modified Foods are foods derived from organisms whose genetic material (DNA) has been modified in a way that does not occur naturally, for example, through the introduction of a gene from a different organism.” This includes plants, microorganisms or animals. WHO further expound that these “existing genetically modified crops have been developed to improve yield, through the introduction of resistance to plant diseases or of increased tolerance of herbicides.”  In short, these Genetically Modified foods are “modern biotechnology” or “genetic engineering” and as a result there will be an increased chemical used in the agriculture in order to improve yield.
Many countries have brought their concerns about the Genetically Modified foods due to its process including the Philippines, wherein the Supreme Court bans the development of genetically engineered products until only “when agriculture department promulgates new rules that will more sufficiently comply with the country’s biosafety framework and international protocols.” (Interaksyon news)
In the question on whether the courts should interfere in matters involving regulation of Genetically Modified Food, yes, I do agree that courts should interfere. Genetically Modified foods might as well cause public health effects and environmental impacts in our agriculture. We should be aware that even though, these Genetically Modified foods have passed several safety assessments conducted by national authorities, there is still no available safety assurance, in fact according to the World Health Organization (WHO), GM foods’ assurance should be assessed on a “case-by-case basis”. Due to the increased use of chemicals in the agriculture, we cannot deny that different public concerns might arise, particularly, the concern for human health.
Therefore, there being a human or public concern involved, the courts should interfere as it is their duty of care to ensure the safety of its people regardless of the benefits of these Genetically Modified foods.


Reference:


http://www.interaksyon.com/article/121368/first-in-the-world--supreme-court-bans-development-of-genetically-engineered-products

Friday, January 8, 2016

No Bio, No Boto

The changes brought by the advancement in information technology are beneficial. One of the products therein is biometrics. The before manual registration on elections now turned into registration through biometrics. Filipinos must register in the biometrics to be able to vote. Failure to do so will stop them from voting in the current elections.

The first of this kind of registration happened in the previous presidential elections. One may not be able to register twice under two or more different names since biometrics is already used. The fraud may be lessened this way if not totally eliminated. On the otherhand, anyone who failed to register through the biometrics cannot vote. This is I think reasonable. To be able to enjoy this right, one must follow the procedures laid down by law. The law requires that one must register in order to check if he has all the qualifications set by our Constitution.

According to the Constitution, the right to suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines not otherwise disqualified by law, who are at least eighteen years old and who shall have resided in the Philippines for at least one year, and in place where they propose to vote for at least six months prior the election. Those who failed to register are rendered disqualified from exercising their rights to suffrage.

According to the Omnibus Election Code, it shall be the obligation of  every voter qualified to vote to register and cast his vote. Therefore, those who failed to register through biometrics cannot vote.

This is just an evolution of the previous manual registration where people who also failed to register are not allowed to vote. There was just a change in the means of registering. One may vote so long as he has the qualifications laid down by law supported through his registration.

No bio no boto and the manana habit.

The right to vote or suffrage is the most essential right a citizen of a democratic country has; its exercise truly shows that the government is really represented by its people. Our constitution states “Suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines not otherwise disqualified by law”  these words written in our constitution indicates how powerful the said right here in our country. It clearly states that no law shall disqualify a qualified citizen to participate in an election. But what if a law requiring a mandatory biometric registration which if not complied shall stated in the law “be deactivated” from voting?

The “No bio, no boto policy” a law which purpose is to establish a clean, complete, permanent and updated list to adapt to the modernization of elections, it is also intended to prevent flying and ghost voters. The comelec gave an ample time for the public to comply with this policy religiously campaigned for its success. However, knowing us Filipinos being guilty of manana habit made around 3 million registered voters fail to comply. 3 million is serious number of citizens that can be denied of its right to suffrage.

A party list questioned the constitutionality of the law governing the policy on the no bio no boto policy arguing that the policy adds a substantive requirement for the citizens to exercise to exercise their right. The party list also said that it is unreasonable to deprive a constitutional right just because of failure to provide biometrics even though the said citizen is a registered voter. The SC rejected the party list’s argument and said that “registering is only one step towards voting, and it is not one of the elements that makes a citizen a qualified voter,”

In my opinion, the constitution is clear about what it stated that no law should disqualify a person exercising its right to vote. Validation thru biometrics is a great step for the modernization and I believe that it will serve it purpose. However, I also believe the failure to comply shall deactivate or should I say deprive a person to vote is truly unconstitutional. It is a very high price to pay just for the failure to comply of the said policy which not an essential requirement for being a qualified voter.

It is also hard to think that a simple habit can potentially deprive a person's constitutional right to vote.






Right of the Rightful

By virtue of Republic Act No. 10367 otherwise known as An Act Providing for Mandatory Biometrics Voter Registration, the Commission on Elections launched its #NoBioNoBoto campaign which urged the 4.3 Filipino voters who have not yet submitted their digital photographs, signatures and fingerprints (biometric data for brevity) four months away from the deadline set in 31 October 2015. In a petition of Kabataan party-list group, it was alleged that the program would disenfranchise some 2.4 million registered voters without biometric data in their registration records who failed to comply with the said Act within the deadline. The Supreme Court, however, upheld the program and ruled that only voters who had their biometric data will be allowed to vote in next year’s general elections. This led to the outbreak of different reactions.

I would like to emphasize just one important point why this development in the field of Philippine Election is aptly and timely. 

Employing the biometric data system would ensure that the right to suffrage would only be granted to and exercised by those who are qualified as provided by the Constitution to wit: “Suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines not otherwise disqualified by law, who are at least eighteen years of age, and who shall have resided in the Philippines for at least one year, and in the place wherein they propose to vote, for at least six months immediately preceding the election. No literacy, property, or other substantive requirement shall be imposed on the exercise of suffrage.” I acknowledge that suffrage is a fundamental right and is inherent to every Filipino citizen. However, in as much as we wanted to exercise such right must be an interest to be entitled to it. It is our duty as voters to prove that we satisfactorily meet the qualifications laid down by law. The biometric data would make this possible. 

Considering the time given by the Commission on Elections, I believe it is ample enough for the registered voters to validate their biometric data in authorized offices. However, millions still failed to comply. Now they are saying that the #NoBioNoBoto would deprive them of their rights to suffrage. Having failed to spare an hour or a couple of hours to show up as qualified voters and submit their biometric data, I say, these voters blew their own rights away. 



No Bio, No boto: A change and not a burden

Llamas, Roberto Stefan S.
JD 4102
No Bio, No Boto

               Every time elections are held in the country, whether from small baranggay elections to the big ones like Senetorial or Presidential elections, there are always issues that resurfaces, issues which includes; non-registered voters, the qualifications of voters, dead voters that somehow casted their votes, and the all encompassing one, vote buying. However the issue that the No Bio, No boto scheme wants to eradicate is that there are unregistered voters that voted and there are deceased voters that could cast their votes. Members of the public have different stands on this Law, some agree while others disapprove to such.

                     The Kabataan party-list was one who disapproves. According to the Kabataan party-list, the said law was unconstitutional as it would deprive ones rights to vote and that it would disenfranchise millions of voters. They’re contention was that the law created a “substantial requirement” other than those provide under the 1987 Constitution regarding Suffrage. However the Supreme Court argues that it does not bar any person from voting, the law is merely a step for one to vote and does not add another requirement. The SC further contends that the regulation was narrowly tailored to achieve the compelling state interest of establishing a clean, complete, permanent and updated list of voters, and was demonstrably the least restrictive means to promote that interest.

               I agree with what the SC ruled as their decision. The law is created not to deprive ones right to vote, but rather to filter those who can vote. It is about time that there would somewhat be a guaranteed way that the elections this year could be clean as to who gets to vote. In terms of clean and filtered, there would no longer be mysterious votes cast beyond the grave and that those who fraudulently uses someone else’s identity would be eradicated and many more of such troubling problems that every time elections arrive.

               Honestly there is no trouble at all upon getting ones biometrics and reassuring to oneself that they can vote. The big questions now falls to ones morality, either if they would be diligent enough to make sure they could get their biometrics or if their laziness would prevail. Sure, there are some people who would be aggravated if they were not informed of such a change. It would now be the responsibility of the government to inform every person, and the public to know what is the changes to the voting system.

               This is not a question whether ones right is violated or not, but rather it is a question if one would allow the change and be responsible enough to make the change. Like any other change that comes into our country, either big or small, there will be a lot who would oppose, either that their rights were violated, their principles or demands were not met, or just because the crab-mentality the we Filipinos have that makes us just join the band wagon and oppose without any reason. Be as it may, change is coming, whether we accept it or not, we do need how we chose the next leaders of our country, and that starts with who would chose which leader that may be.   

No Bio, No Boto: Substantial Right vs. Procedural Requirement

2016 has arrived and for us, Filipinos, this is a very important year as we are about to have the next president who will be taking over our country for the next six years. With the upcoming general elections in May, many candidates have promised to bring about change in our country. The kind of change that we, Filipinos, have craved for in years and are very excited to witness and be part of. However, with the new “No Bio, No Boto” policy of the Commission of Elections (Comelec), the voices of about 2.5 million voters will not be heard simply because they have not been fingerprinted or photographed.

On February 15, 2013, President Benigno S. Aquino III approved the Republic Act No. 10367 (An Act Providing For Mandatory Biometrics Voter Registration). This act, which is more commonly known as the “No Bio, No Boto” policy, states that all registered voters must be able to have their biometric data recorded in order for them to vote in this year’s general elections. The purpose of this policy, according to the Comelec, is to “cleanse the national voter registry so as to eliminate electoral fraud.” This policy has been contested by the Kabataan Party-list group led by Terry Ridon, claiming that the new policy is unconstitutional as it limits the democratic right to suffrage of those people who were not able to have their biometric data recorded. However, on December 16, 2015, the Supreme Court has unanimously decided to uphold the “No Bio, No Boto” policy prohibiting  about 2.5 million people to vote this upcoming elections.

Personally, I believe that this decision is a major impediment in our electoral process. The right to vote is what makes each citizen of a democratic country like ours powerful as he or she is given the ability to elect the leaders of our country. This right is even enshrined in our Constitution. A right that cannot simply be taken away by the mere lack of biometric data of a voter who has already been considered as a registered voter in the first place. 

According to Section 1, Article 5 of the 1987 Constitution, “suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines, not otherwise disqualified by law, who are at least eighteen years of age, and who shall have resided in the Philippines for at least one year and in the place wherein they propose to vote, for at least six months immediately preceding the election. No literacy, property, or other substantive requirement shall be imposed on the exercise of suffrage.”

There are several grounds that can disqualify a person from voting according to Section 11 of the Republic Act No. 8189 (An Act Providing For A General Registration Of Voters, Adopting A System Of Continuing Registration, Prescribing The Procedures Thereof And Authorizing The Appropriation Of Funds Therefor). These include conviction of a crime punishable by more than one year of imprisonment, conviction of any crime involving disloyalty to the duly constituted government, or by being declared as an insane or incompetent person. I guess it is safe to say that these are very serious grounds compared to the mere non-compliance of undergoing the biometrics process.

I understand and agree with what Comelec wishes to achieve with this new policy and I do not think that requiring voters to undergo biometrics should be an issue but to punish voters by disqualifying them from voting because of non-compliance is unreasonable and greatly contradicts what the true meaning of democracy is. The government should not take a substantial right away from its citizens simply because of non-compliance of a mere procedural requirement that does not even bear any factor on the individual’s capacity to vote with discernment. 

Lastly, some would argue that merely 2.5 million voters will be affected but in a tight race like the one  that we currently have between the presidential candidates, those 2.5 million votes can make a  big difference. 



  



ELECTIONS gets a modernization boost


Modernization is an inevitable part of a progressive society and does affect almost every aspect of a person’s everyday life. As the New Year 2016 begins a good number of people are already looking forward to May as this year is Election season for the Philippines and it too gets its own boost of modernization. But even though the intent of modernization has always been progress it does meet its own set of controversies. At the forefront now in Election related controversies is the much needed technological boost brought about by the Biometrics System and the implementation of Republic Act No. 10367: An Act Providing for Mandatory Biometrics Voter Registration.  
At a certain perspective you can definitely discern the anomalies this new system would address. At full implementation this new system would certainly reduce or perhaps eliminate a number of election anomalies like Flying voters and ghost voters to merely an election urban legend. We certainly do not know why a process like this which has seemingly obvious benefits still gets to have its own controversy instead of the 100% nod of everyone. Sadly enough this one does have one too as a group led by the Kabataan partylist were briefly successful in stopping the full implementation of R.A. No. 10367 and its effects by taking their case of opposing the “No Bio, No Vote” policy of the COMELEC for the 2016 elections to the Supreme Court and was able to secure a temporary restraining order on the rule. But as mentioned it was short lived as the TRO is now dismissed and thus making the “No Bio, No Boto” policy of the COMELEC implementable this coming May elections.
As commendable as it is for them to show their eagerness in exercising their right to vote I believe that the enthusiasm they are showing is a bit misplaced. The Right to Suffrage is both a citizen’s privilege and responsibility. The voting population is actually privileged to have our own government working on implementing a system that is aimed to cleanup a reputably controversial method of electing our leaders. I believe that in order to show our gratitude to our government for doing this it is our responsibility to heed to the implementing rules and go out and do our are part in making this undertaking successful. I understand that they are not opposing the Biometric System per se but rather they are fighting for the right of those who failed to comply with the new rule as the implementation was not as efficient as everyone hoped as they were met with long lines and crowds that overwhelmed and thus were unable to accommodate a few who were there to fulfill their side of the deal. But then again I believe we should all agree that the purpose for this new system would be a benefit to us all. Yes it is sad that these group will not be able to take part in the coming election despite their eagerness to do so but to make the glass half-full, as we are a society that puts a high premium on freedom the coming elections will certainly be not the last that they take part of. With the Biometrics system fully implement we hope that it give us a cleaner election and with it the real voice of the people will be heard and the people that will emerge victorious will be the real leaders that the people want to be serving country.
God bless us all this coming May 2016.