Friday, January 8, 2016

No Bio, No Boto: Upheld

Leaders are chosen by the people. For people to effectively choose a leader, they themselves must be qualified to vote. Our constitution provides the requirements of a voter. These requirements are very basic but important. Citizens already know these requirements on top of their heads since they have been practicing the right for many years.

“No Bio, No Boto” was signed by the President last 2013. This did not escape the critical public. Many strongly opposed the promulgation of this law because they felt that it is an additional requirement for voters. Right away, they saw this implementation is an impediment in exercising their rights.

Kabataan party-list group was questioning the constitutionality of RA 10367 and other COMELEC resolutions. They are mainly arguing that it is a violation of the constitutional right of the Filipinos to vote because they will not be able to do so despite existing and active registration if they fail to register their biometric information. But the Supreme Court upheld the new system. They said that it is just one step towards voting and it is not one of the elements that qualifies a citizen to vote.

The first thing they noticed was the negative side of the implementation. First, they will have to line up again or technically register again. Second, they believe having their information stored is just another temporary thing. For them these altogether is a waste of their time and effort. Little did they know that this would help make the process or the system easier in the future.

Easy is just one part. Security is another. The process is, capturing the biometrics of the voting public and storing them for future elections. This will not only help in faster pulling up of information but also to avoid the usual crimes committed during election. Fraudulent activities are rampant during elections. This system is mainly focusing on the authenticity of the information of the voters. No two persons have the same fingerprint. Their pictures are also taken for further verification purposes. These steps are both for the security of the public and their votes.

Many tried to comply despite the opposition of others. Even the senior citizens lined up and had their biometrics captured. A lot of people even registered at the last minute just to make sure that they will be able to vote on the 2016 elections.

I personally believe that the voting public understands the objective of the government. And like in many cases, not everyone will agree with a project or a proposal for change. But the COMELEC launched this campaign, was signed by the president, and was successfully implemented as expected.



Cleansing the National Voter Registry: SC Upholds "No Bio, No Boto"

“Voting is the most precious right of every citizen, and we have a moral obligation to ensure the integrity of our voting process.” –Hillary Clinton

Various youth groups feared that the constitutional right to suffrage was put in jeopardy when the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) launched its “No Bio, No Boto” policy. The Kabataan Party-List, along with other youth and student organizations, filed a petition for certiorari and prohibition with the Supreme Court assailing the constitutionality of Republic Act 10367 or the “Mandatory Biometrics Registration Act of 2013”.

Under RA 10367, the COMELEC is mandated to “implement a mandatory biometrics registration system for new voters”[1] in order “to establish a clean, complete, permanent and updated list of voters through the adoption of biometric technology.”[2] On the other hand, “registered voters whose biometrics have not been captured shall submit themselves for validation”.[3] As for those with incomplete biometrics data and those corrupted data (biometrics) in the database, the COMELEC clarified, in Resolution No. 10013, that their registration records “shall not be deactivated and be allowed to vote in the May 9, 2016 Synchronized National, Local and [Autonomous Region on Muslim Mindanao (ARMM)] Regional Elections.”

The petitioners in this case raise the following issues— (1) that biometrics validation rises to the level of an additional, substantial qualification where there is penalty of deactivation; (2) that biometrics deactivation is not the disqualification by law contemplated by the 1987 Constitution; (3) that biometrics validation gravely violates the Constitution, considering that, applying the strict scrutiny test, it is not poised with a compelling reason for state regulation and hence, an unreasonable deprivation of the right to suffrage; (4) that voters to be deactivated are not afforded due process; and (5) that poor experience with biometrics should serve as warning against exacting adherence to the system.[4]

On the first issue and second issue, the Court explained that what is meant by ‘substantive requirement’ in Section 1, Article V of the 1987 Constitution are purely socio-economic considerations that have “no bearing on the right of a citizen to intelligently cast his vote and to further the public good.”[5] To further contextualize this point, the Court showed the evolution of voting in the Philippines— how requirements of literacy and property were eliminated so as increase the electoral base and allow for a more inclusive representation. The Court also went on to differentiate “registration” (as a form of regulation) and “qualification”. Registration, according to the Court (and emphasized in Justice Leonen’s concurring opinion), is merely a means to determine if the voter has the necessary qualifications to vote. Biometrics is a procedural and not a substantive requirement.

On the third issue, the Court held that RA 10367 passed the strict scrutiny test. ‘Strict scrutiny’ is used to test the validity of laws dealing with the regulation of speech, gender, or race as well as other fundamental rights. It refers to “the standard for determining the quality and the amount of governmental interest brought to justify the regulation of fundamental freedoms”.[6] In applying the strict scrutiny test, there must be a compelling state interest and an absence of a less restrictive means for achieving that interest.  The Court found the perennial problem of flying voters, and dead and multiple registrants a compelling state interest; there is a need, in the words of Senator Aquilino Pimentel III, “to cleanse the national voter registry so as to eliminate electoral fraud and ensure that the results of the elections were truly reflective of the genuine will of the people.”[7]

On the fourth issue, the Court took into consideration the efforts made by the COMELEC and the realities of registration [of voters] and elections. The Court thought that the time frame and procedures instituted by the COMELEC was reasonable, and that it afforded everyone an opportunity to be heard. The Court pointed out that the law became effective as early as 2013, and that registration period lasted at least 18 months.

And on the last issue, the Court found the petitioners’ argument on the efficiency of the biometric system as observed from the experiences of other countries as a political question. The petitioners’ submissions assail the wisdom of the policy, a matter which is outside the province of the judiciary. Such concern should be addressed to the political branches of the government.

To conclude, the “No Bio, No Boto” policy does not expand the qualifications provided by the Constitution; it is a merely a procedural requirement aimed to “enhance the fundamental right [of suffrage”. There is a compelling state interest in cleansing the national voter registry with the use of new technology to prevent electoral fraud and make elections truly representative of the will of the people. The COMELEC has taken fair and reasonable measures to afford citizens a chance to register, and it is upon each individual to fulfill his or her responsibility regardless of the inconvenience that may be caused.





[1] Section 10, RA 10367
[2] Section 1, RA 10367
[3] Section 2 (d), RA 10367
[4] Kabataan Party List, et al. v. Commission on Elections, G.R. No. 221318 (The Supreme Court December 16, 2015).
[5] Id.
[6] Id.
[7] Id.

Biometrics: Boon or Bane of Our Right to Suffrage


I remember when I was in college, I was so eager to vote for the first time for the 2010 national elections. My mother told me to go to the COMELEC Office during that summer of 2009 to register as a voter. It was a relatively painless process, as I was in and out of the Comelec satellite office in Makati in less than an hour. This was including filling up the form, encoding of the data into the database and taking of my picture and biometric information. Fast forward a few months after, my peers would be lining up to register when it was already days before the October 31, 2009 deadline. Hearing the stories of lining up for one whole day and failing to be accommodated due to the volume of people for that day. These experiences would have made the act of exercising the right of suffrage a bane for the potential voter registrants. 

Fast forward to 2013, President Benigno Aquino passes Republic Act 10367 or the Mandatory Biometrics Law where all registered voters are required to have their biometrics registered to be able to vote for the 2016 national elections. This is where the campaign of COMELEC "No Bio, No Boto Policy" campaign comes into play. COMELEC has been urging the voting population to actually check in their official website if their registration is complete with biometrics. Several infomercials and social media posts were shared in different social networking sites to raise the awareness of this campaign. The COMELEC even opened the biometric registration in several locations including shopping malls around the metro. Nonetheless, true to the Filipino behavior of delaying until the October 31 deadline is already near, people brushed off this campaign to the last minute. The same stories of long lines, frustrated people and malfunctioning equipment can be seen in the news. Hence, a petition for certiorari and prohibition was filed by the Kabataan Partylist and other youth groups last November 25, 2015 to the Supreme Court to strike the "no bio, no boto" policy as unconstitutional since according to the petitioners " it violates due process as it is an unreasonable deprivation of the constitutional right to vote for failure to register their biometric information despite existing and active registration". The main contention of the petition is that approximately 3 million voters who have failed to register their biometric information shall be ineligible to vote during the 2016 national elections. (1) 

 In December 1, 2015, the SC granted a TRO against the "No boto, no bio" policy postponing the preparation of the COMELEC regarding the 2016 national election since they will not be able to finalize the list of the voters. This was a temporary victory for the petitioners since the right of those who have not been able to register their biometric information will still have a chance to vote in the 2016 elections. (2) However on December 16, 2015, the SC ultimately junked the TRO against the "no boto, no bio policy" as it is not deemed as unconstitutional since it does not raise the registration requirement of eligible voters but is rather is just a qualification to cleanse the current voter registry and prevent future electoral fraud in the upcoming 2016 national elections. (3) 

With the lifting of the TRO against the biometric voter's registration, the COMELEC can now ultimately update and finalize the voters database since there are prevalent cases of ghost and flying voters from the previous elections. With the biometric registration, the COMELEC will be able to now cross check if the voters are still active and existing to date. Therefore, it should not be considered as a bane to the right of suffrage but rather a boon since the votes will be sure to have come from a unique individual who matches the biometric information registration which is a step closer hopefully to a cleaner and fraud-free 2016 national elections. 
Sources: 
 1. Declare ‘No Bio, No Boto’ unconstitutional, SC asked (Nov 26, 2015, Philippines) Last accessed from: http://www.rappler.com/nation/politics/elections/2016/114575-sc-tro-comelec-biometrics-no-bio-no-boto 

 2.SC stops Comelec from dropping 2.5M voters without biometrics (Dec 1, 2015, Philippines) Last accessed from: http://www.rappler.com/nation/politics/elections/2016/114013-no-bio-no-boto-unconstitutional-sc 

 3. SC junks petition vs 'No Bio, No Boto' policy (Dec 16, 2015, Philippines) Last accessed from: http://www.rappler.com/nation/politics/elections/2016/116113-sc-junks-petition-against-no-bio-no-boto-policy

Right or Obligation: Suffrage

Voting is a right vested on people under a democratic country. The citizens have the right to choose their leaders. According to the Philippine Constitution, all the citizens may vote unless disqualified by law. One must also be eighteen years of age and has been residing in the Philippines for at least a year and at least six months in the place they plan to vote preceding the election. If all these were followed, voting will not be a problem.

For years now, people have been manually voting. Early on, the government wanted to improve the system by employing PCOS machines. For many, this has not helped the voting system in the Philippines at all. Instead, it has created a lot of issues. In 2013, President Aquino signed RA 10367. Again, this raised a lot of questions and contentions between party-lists and the government.

“No Bio, No Boto” was launched by the COMELEC. This angered a lot of citizens. Most felt that this is unconstitutional and a certain party-list even filed for a temporary restraining order. The reason for the commotion is, all previously registered voters without biometrics will have to subject themselves to biometrics capture. If they do not, then they cannot vote. A strict compliance to the requirement was promulgated. They felt this was an added requirement violating the constitutional provision.

Embracing a change is very difficult for a lot of people. This would mean getting out of your comfort zones. This was probably what most of the citizens felt that is why they strongly opposed the “No Bio, No Boto” system. I admire the dedication the citizens of this country have just to be able to vote. I have personally witnessed how they tried to comply. I was one with the many who registered late and had to line up early in the morning and finish the whole process in the afternoon. This only means that people really want to vote and exercise their rights. But a little discomfort now will not hurt if in the future, it will make the system more easy and efficient.

The people’s complaints are mainly because the effort they have to exert when they have been comfortable with the outdated way of voting. Manual registration and voting is nearly passé. I know a lot of people getting away with double registration or fly-voting or even voting on behalf of other people who cannot vote. The government, on its part wants to regulate and make the system easy to avoid any untoward events. Truly, having to go through the biometrics capture is an added requirement for voters. But this is a one-time requirement. Once you have had your information captured, it will be stored in the database for future use.

I regret that I have been irresponsible when it comes to exercising my right to suffrage. I felt the guilt of not having the same dedication others have. I registered late while others have registered on time. While I have all the valid reasons in the world why I was not able to comply early on, I believe others had their own reasons too. But since I knew I was somehow at fault, I had to embrace the change that the government want to effect to ease the long process in the long run. Other groups who continue to oppose this will just have to accept and see the good side of the “No Bio, No Boto” campaign. This will instill discipline to each one of us. It just goes to say, if there is a will, there is a way. Their dedication must equal their efforts. If they strongly want to vote, then they must do whatever it takes for them to qualify to the requirements. COMELEC came up with other solutions like setting up satellite offices in malls.

For now, suffrage is still a right that we citizens of this country may enjoy but at the same time we have to comply with the requirements. We may feel obliged because of the requirements, but these will surely benefit us all in the future.




No Bio, No Boto: One of the means to an end

No Bio, No Boto: One of the means to an end

The right to suffrage may only be exercised by qualified Filipino citizens.

Aside from the requirements in our Constitution, another law sets a requirement for the voters.  The Republic Act No. 10637 requires all voter registration records to have biometric information.[1] RA 10367 defines the Biometric as ”the quantitative analysis that provides a positive identification of an individual such as voice, photograph, fingerprint, signature, iris and/or such other identifiable features.”

The COMELEC scheduled the biometric registration period both for new and old voters from May 6, 2014 to October 31, 2015.[2] Despite of this long duration of registration, more than two million Filipinos are left unregistered making them disqualified to vote for the upcoming May 2016 elections. This resulted to filing of a petition to declare the policy unconstitutional in which the Supreme Court dismissed.

I have been voting since 2009 and been hearing a lot of elections problems. I do believe that the cleaning of voters' list will eliminate one of the several issues that repeatedly arose in the past elections. 

I sympathize to those who will not be able to exercise their right to vote next year. But I also believe that COMELEC made its earnest efforts to remind the voters to do their responsibility. The Commission opened satelite offices in the malls and extended their working days and hours just to accomodate millions of concerned Filipino voters. COMELEC also lainched its Huling Hirit campaign for the cramming voters during the last two weeks of registration. The biometric registration for voters lasted for more than one year hence there is no acceptable excuses to those who failed to comply. However, COMELEC should have been considerate enough to extend the registration even just for a few days due to the typhoon in October which prevented the voters to go out and register. 

I understand that millions of voters can still make a differerence to the results of elections. We also have to bear in mind that if those voters who failed to comply really care for the future of our country, they should have been more than willing to spend a weekday or a weekend to register.

This is just one of the programs od COMELEC for a cleaner and more honest elections in the coming years. As a Filipino, we have to give our support by doing what the law requires us to do.

-----------------------------------
[1] No Bio, No Boto: http://www.comelec.gov.ph/?r=VoterRegistration/NoBioNoBoto
August 22,2015

[2] No Bio, No Boto COMELC reminds 4.3 million Pinoys: Registration only until Oct. 31,2015: http://www.interaksyon.com/article/112029/no-bio-no-boto--comelec-reminds-4-3-million-pinoys-registration-only-until-oct--31
June 9, 2015

Poor System of Election: The Need for Enhancement

Poor System of Election: The Need for Enhancement

What is No Bio, No Boto campaign?

When Republic Act No. 10367 “An Act Providing for Mandatory Biometrics Voter Registration” was signed into law, it then requires all voter registration records to have biometrics information. According to the official site of the Commission on Elections, “When you go to your local COMELEC office, your biometrics data will be captured using the COMELEC’s Voter’s Registration Machine. The VRM makes use of a digital camera, a fingerprint scanner and a signature pad to capture your biometrics data." Therefore, your biometrics consists of your picture, your fingerprints and your signature.  The Act comply all registered voters to undergo through the validation procedure to be able to vote in the May 2016 elections, failure to comply with validation process of Republic Act No. 10367 will deactivate the registration record of the registered voter from the precinct book of voters.

We have to consider the fact that the use of different form of electoral frauds in our system of election is a long-time dilemma and rampant in the Philippines which is due to having a lighter take on people's information during the election period. For example, the person can fake her or his information to be registered in their corresponding precinct book of voters. Another form of electoral fraud which is rampant in our country is the Dead People Voting wherein the name of a deceased person remains on the official list of registered voters and a living person fraudulently casts a vote in the name of that deceased person. Therefore, as the result of these uncontrolled electoral frauds in our county, I concurred with the #NoBioNoBoto campaign of the COMELEC. I believed this validation procedure will at least lessen our problems in terms of an election.

Hence, the process is reasonable for the purpose of law. The fact that it ensures the authenticity of the information of the voters; it is also a way to enhance cleanliness and orderliness of our poor system of election.

We have to consider things in order to change our poor system of election. We can never attain our ideal system of election if we use the same standards which are no longer sufficient and helpful to us.





Reference:

http://www.comelec.gov.ph/

Suffrage, Not Just A Right But A Responsibility.



May 2016 is fast approaching, and it is almost time again for us to vote for the people we see qualified to lead us for the next three to nine years. From early last year, the government has been preparing for the upcoming historical event. They have been endlessly resolving election related issues such as the qualifications of those running for office. One issue that is equally important as a politician’s qualification that needs to be addressed is the validity of the registered electorate.

Because of numerous election fraud throughout our political history, the Government, through Republic Act 10367, provided a way to ensure a clean and updated list of voters. It required voters, registered or new, to submit personally their biometric data which includes the voter’s picture, fingerprints and signature. By registering these data with the Voters Registration Machine (VRM), it can be ensured that each person is registered only once, and that all registered names are persons existing who are physically and civilly capable of voting.

The Comelec has been pushing with their “No Bio No Boto” campaign, it provides the deactivation of registered voters who fails to submit their biometrics, which results to not being able to vote. They were only given until October 31, 2015 to update their registration.

It is a big step by the government to ensure the sanctity of the electorate during election. It is only right that they verify each voter and it is also within their power to do so. People may have the right of suffrage but it is also the Government’s responsibility to ensure it is exercised properly. The people should, therefore, also be responsible as citizens. The campaign does not necessarily strip the people of their right but rather implements a stricter regulation on the procedures, it actually protects the welfare of the public by preventing fraudulent acts which sabotages the voice of the electorate.

The Government also needs enough time to prepare and make sure everything is furnished, this allows them to minimize problems on Election Day. With this, they have given the voters time to update their registration in accordance with law. It is now the voters’ responsibility to meet these voting requirements.

However, with the exponential growth of technology, I think the government can afford to give more time for the voters to update their registration. Giving a better chance that a bigger number of people can vote.

In the end, it is up to everyone to ensure an honest and clean election. We all should take responsibility in one of our most important right because it is our duty to do so. It is the future of our nation that is at stake here. We should not be complaining about the Governments performance if we ourselves would not be vigilant and responsible.