Friday, January 15, 2016

SC Ruling bans GMO crops: Keeping it safe is eating safe

Everybody eats and what we eat is as unique and is as different as each individual is from each other. Food is as basic a human need as breathing which then establishes the relevancy to each person walking this earth the issue of Genetically Modified Organisms or GMOs. In today’s calamity filled world innovation has lent its hand to certain plants and crops in order for it to withstand the ever changing ecology. But not every mad-made change is welcomed with open arms by another as some sectors are quick to raise the dangers this GMOs can bring us.
                We are who we eat and that saying reflects no better than to us Filipinos as a recent decision by the Supreme Court left a permanent ban on field trials of GMO eggplants and a temporary halt on approving applications for the “contained use, import, commercialization and propagation” of GMO crops, including the import of GMO products.[1] In all honesty, as a consumer I knew that GMO plants were already existing in the world but did not know that it was as close to home than it is now. I am still at a belief that the farmers tilling our lands are “old school” and are bereft of any technological innovation and have been planting the way generations before them have. As alarmed as I am of this controversy I am also relieved that our Courts took the side of caution on this matter. According to Greenpeace, who is the group responsible for taking this matter to court, is airing that even though this GMO crops are proven to withstand the forces of nature there have been no ironclad proof that these same GMO plants are safe when consumed by people as compared to their unaltered counterparts. I understand that the technological reason for creating GMO plants is because without plants that can withstand the test of worsening environmental calamities then the population’s supply might eventually get to levels that would not be able to meet demand. As noble the cause may be I believe there should be no shortcuts in order to address that concern. The sensitivity of the matter brings the concern right to our own dinner table and to that I am glad our Supreme Court has leaned to the side of caution on this matter. Yes it is right for science to find a way to address the demands of society but not at all cost and to that the Supreme Court upholds our right which as stated in the Constitution that “The State shall protect and advance the right of the people to a balanced and healthful ecology in accord with the rhythm and harmony of nature”. I believe GMOs will soon become more a part of our lives than it is today but what the Supreme Court I think implies in this decision is that it should be done the right way and the welfare of the people that will consume it should be the first and foremost consideration.           

Reference

[1]   http://ecowatch.com/2015/12/14/gmos-philippines/

Courts: The Philippines Is Still Not Ready For GMOs

The Philippines is considered a third world country. Why? In terms of infrastructures, we are behind. Population growth is incontrollable. Not to mention the heavy traffic and poor inflation rate. All these sum up to our incapability to provide top of the line scientific research tools.

Research is the key to improvement. While we are too agog in improving everything all at once, there are just some things that cannot be hurriedly done. In the recent decision of the Supreme Court on the field testing of Bt Talong, it was held that it is void and should be stopped.

One of the petitioners of the case was Greenpeace. It is a non-governmental organization that aims to protect the future from further destruction. According to its page, greenpeace promotes the welfare of the people, the environment and detests environmental criminals and companies that are not able to live up to the promises to safeguard the environment.

While the respondents’ aim was to provide shortcut in production of crops that are staples in our daily lives, it was not enough a reason to disregard the effects of artificial additives and genetic engineering to the source of our food and medicine.

In the United States, there are three bodies that regulate the genetically modified crops. In the Philippines, there are also three institutions. Namely, The National Committee on Biosafety of the Philippines (NCBP) under the Department of Science and Technology (DOST) with the aid of the Departments of Agriculture (DA), Environment (DENR) and the Health (DOH), The Department of Agriculture (DA) via the Bureau of Plant Industry’s (BPI) Biotech Core Team (BCT); and the so-called independent Scientific and Technical Review Panel (STRP). These three are in charge of the biosafety, risk assessment and regulation for all GMOs that enter the Philippines.

The question is, whether the Philippine courts are correct in interfering with the regulation of genetically modified food. Generally speaking, the judiciary is part of the government. And the government’s main objective is always for the betterment of its citizens and country. In ruling in favor of the petitioners, the courts were only deciding based on the facts presented to them and based on the fact that, general welfare should be upheld.

Based on the constitution, Judicial power includes the duty of the courts of justice to settle actual controversies involving rights which are legally demandable and enforceable, and to determine whether or not there has been a grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction on the part of any branch or instrumentality of the Government. This sums up my view on why for me, the courts have the right to interfere. A case was presented because the petitioners file a writ of kalikasan alleging that Bt talong trials violate their constitutional right health and balanced ecology. During fact finding and further arguments, they found that safety will be on the line if further field testings on Bt talong will be continued. They were, but doing their job.

Stop the GMO: Stunting the Philippines' Potential Agricultural Development

Genetically modified (GM) foods as defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) are "foods derived from organisms whose genetic material (DNA) has been modified in a way that does not occur naturally[1]". Presently, most of the available genetically modified food is in the form of crops which have been imported by different countries in the world to increase the production yield as demanded by the increasing world population.

In the Philippines, the Department of Agriculture issued Administrative Order No. 8 Series of 2002 entitled "Rules and Regulation on Importation & Release into the Environment of Plants and Plant Products derived from the use of Modern Bio Technology". [2]This issuance was a move to develop the Agricultural Sector in the Philippines with the introduction of using modern biotechnology in developing our crops[3]. A scientific research center was built in the University of the Philippines Los Banos to field test all GM crops such as corn, eggplant and rice.

There were several oppositions received from environmental groups regarding this move of the government. One petition filed by Greenpeace Philippines and farmers' group Masipag against UPLB, UP Mindanao, Department of Agriculture and Department of Environment and Natural Resources last 2012 was against the nationwide field testing of Bt (Bacillus Thuringiensis) Eggplant[4]. As a form of protest, several Greenpeace members even tried to destroy the field testing areas of the Bt Eggplant. [5]In their petition, the primary contention of the petitioners was that there were uncertainties in the safety of consumption of GM foods and the possibility of cross breeding may disrupt natural diversity. [6] In 2013, the Court of Appeals issued a decision halting the nationwide testing of Bt eggplant on the grounds that the existing regulations of DA and DOST are not sufficient to establish the safety of these GM crops to the people and environment. It was also noted that the assailed Admin Order No. 8 is not compliance with the National Biosafety Framework as stipulated in Executive Order No. 514[7]. As an answer to the petition, the Supreme Court issued a Writ of Kalikasan to temporarily stop the field testing of Bt Talong within that same year as this was considered a violation in the constitutional right to balanced and healthy ecology. [8]

However, in the recent decision of the Supreme Court which consolidated all pending petitions regarding this issue on GM crops is the case of International Service for the Acquisition of Agri Biotech Applications, Inc. v. Greenpeace Southeast Asia (Philippines)[9]. The court rules that the conduct of field testing of Bt talong is to be permanently stopped and the DA Admin Order No. 8 series of 2002 was declared null and void. The Court finds that there is uncertainty, possibility of irreversible harm and possibility of serious harm in the safety of GM crops to the health of the people who may consume them in the future.

With all these things considered, is this issue considered to be a stunt in our local agricultural development? The simple answer is YES. The introduction of GM foods is with a noble cause, to be able to eradicate decrease in production yield due to pests, natural calamities and other natural causes. [10] With our continuously rising population growth, our natural resources cannot keep up with our demand for consumption hence the need for scientific intervention to increase production in the form of GM foods. With this latest decision from our highest judicial body, our local scientists would be constrained to work only with our natural occurring resources instead of making our crops grow to be disaster and pest resilient which may be helpful to our country in the long run given the effects of climate change in the world. The Supreme Court in this case, should have appreciated this long term effect of the usage of GM crops. Relatively speaking, this may be one of the reasons why our agricultural sector is still considered poorly developed as compared to our neighboring countries in Asia.



[1] http://www.who.int/topics/food_genetically_modified/en/
[2] http://ap.fftc.agnet.org/ap_db.php?id=320&print=1
[3] Supra
[4] http://www.rappler.com/business/industries/247-agriculture/115327-supreme-court-stops-field-testing-bt-talong-gmo
[5] http://ovcre.uplb.edu.ph/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&id=96:controversial-eggplant-reaches-supreme-court
[6] http://www.greenpeace.org/seasia/ph/press/releases/Writ-of-Kalikasan-granted-against-Bt-Talong-field-trials/
[7] http://www.ovcrd.upd.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/EXECUTIVE-ORDER-NO-514.pdf
[8] Id.
[9] http://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/pdf/web/viewer.html?file=/jurisprudence/2015/december2015/209271.pdf
[10] Id.

Genetically Modified Food: Appreciate not Terminate

In the course of history pest and insects have been a problem with farmers in producing healthy and edible crops and other vegetation. Using insecticides are a way to eradicate such invaders; however the crops also pay the price. In this modern time, researchers, agriculturist, and scientist have created a way to eradicate pest and insects without the use of poisonous chemicals, and that is genetically modifying organisms. However doubts to its safety still looms.

               Genetically modified organisms or food are reengineered vegetation wherein scientists were able to modify the genes of a particular crop that when eaten by pest is harmful to them. It is somewhat creating a bug shield for the crops and plants without the need of chemicals.
               A lot of countries have been growing, marketed, and produced such modified food and at the same time given the production of such regulations that must be strictly followed. However it is a different story in our country. Our country’s scientist and research labs for agricultural science have engineered a Bt talong (eggplant). Bt stands for Bacillus thuringiensis, a common soil bacterium that contains a gene which produces a protein harmful to FSB (Fruit and stem borer).  Scientists have incorporated this gene to eggplant to confer insect resistance. A revolutionary way of assisting our farmers in producing more crops without the worry of pest and chemicals. However news have reached the public that our Supreme court have denied and suspended the testing of such experiment. As a defense the high court stated the constitutional provision that the public has the right to a balance and healthy ecological system and that they have doubts as to the safety of the experiment. However scientist from our country, supported by other international scientist, have pleaded the court stating that there are scientific evidence and census as to prove the safety of such organisms.

               With that said, I do believe the Supreme Court was just upholding the law as to protect the public. Stating the Constitutional provision of having a Balance and healthy ecology, the public does deserve an environment as it would be safe. Under our 1987 constitution the General Welfare clause, wherein it provides that the governing body empowered by the document may enact laws to promote the general welfare of the people, sometimes worded as the public welfare. Hence there is nothing to blame for the acts of our courts in making sure the public is safe, even if it means suspending such experiments.

            However, the courts should not permanently suspend such research. The Supreme court, or any other court, could investigate or ponder around other facts as to not spoil the years of research and hard work that scientist and agriculturist have put on finding ways to make crops safer. In the end the research is still about the welfare of the people in a sense that it would provide the public greater quality of crops and vegetation and as well assisting farmers in pursue of a safer means to eradicate pest and at the same save them enough income as not to worry about the pesticides needed.


            Suspending such research will answer nothing, other than just creating another issue that will just distract us from what really needs much attention. The GMO’s may one day provide food for the public when there is shortage, and we will not know that if such research will not be given that chance.  

GMOs, Should The Supreme Court Intervene?



The world’s population today is steadily increasing which makes it harder to live in. Populated area increases while habitable land area decreases, this only means that the land that could supply us with the valuable resources we need also decreases. One of our particular problem is the increasing lack of food supply. Over the centuries we have resulted to ways to maximize our crops. Harvesting more in less time and minimizing loss.

The recent decision of the Supreme Court, which banned GM eggplants and suspended the importation and use of Genetically Modified plants by the Department of Agriculture, is one of the issues that we should carefully take into consideration.

The decision was promulgated as a precautionary measure. It claims that Administrative Order No. 8 of the DA lacks the safety precaution set out by law. They further argue that it is better to err in the side of precaution than to commit uncertain irreversible errors brought by GMOs.

The SC should have not decided in such a way. They should have decided on the petition’s merit and there was no proof that the GMOs had an actual negative effect on anyone or the environment. There was no actual injury. Aside from the fact that the DA is more in a position to determine the negative effects of GMOs, the SC should have decided when there was an actual issue or controversy.

There are many uncertain things in this world and we are all trying to find solutions to the problem. It does not matter if we commit errors, it naturally goes with everything around us.  We use a medicines today, medicines which directly and instantly has an effect on us. Many of them which have not been around for a long time and we are uncertain of its long time effects. Effects which may be irreversible.

The reason why we still use them is because it helps us in our present state. It is an instant solution to problems we are presently facing. Solutions which are not absolute, but helps. Those really proven to have negative effects were thrown out.

We know the SC is our last line of defense when it come to our rights, even our rights to a healthy living. But it is still too early to decide on the problem. What the decision aims is to prevent irreversible error. We can see something as irreversible if it cannot be changed after a very long time. Right now we cannot say we are in imminent danger of an irreversible error.

Lastly, people have the right to choose if they would want to stick to GMOs or ordinary crops. They can choose which they think is best for them. By banning GMOs, people have lost their choice without any evidence to its negative effects.

Court interferes in the food on our table

      Some organisms today are being genetically engineered in the laboratory by including the best physiological traits of another organism. Genetic engineering in organisms entered the field of Agriculture in order to increase crop yield and lessen the use of insecticide which in return will be more favorable to farmers and consumers. The first genetically modified food was approved in the United States in 1994. The widely planted genetically modified foods around the globe are corn and soybean.

      In the Philippines, genetic modification of organisms like corn, rice and eggplant are being studied and field trials are being conducted. One of the latest studies and trials is the introduction of an anti-pest gene from Bacillus thuringiensis to an eggplant.  Several groups filed a case against UPLB Foundation Inc., UP Mindanao Foundation Inc., Department of Environment and Natural Resources, and Department of Agriculture. Supreme Court ruled to stop the field trials and declared the Administrative Order No. 8 (Rules and Regulations for the Importation and Release into Environment of Plants and Plant Products Derived from the Use of Modern Biotechnology) of DA as unconstitutional. 

       Our Constitution states that “The State shall protect and advance the right of the people to a balanced and healthful ecology in accord with the rhythm and harmony of nature”. It is true that we have a right according to the Constitution, but is there something wrong in searching ways on how to improve the crop yield and quality of food?

      There is nothing in the acts of researching and field testing which force all farmers to plant the genetically modified crops, neither planting all agricultural lands with genetically altered plants which may result to violation of our constitutional rights. The research, field trials and the actual cultivation of genetically modified crops are scientific and biotechnological advancement. This advancement will only give an option to farmers and consumers of what they can plant and eat so the research and field testing should not be banned.

      However, court may interfere in the mass farming and cultivation of these genetically modified plants to ensure sufficient availability of naturally bred foods. Filipino consumers should be left with options between the naturally bred and the genetically engineered foods.

Court vs Science

Long ago, the use science of in agriculture was not that widespread, but through time our farmers found it helpful in their work of origin. Before us is an issue of the Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) against Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO), particularly, the Bt Talong. Bt talong is defined by the International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications (ISAAA) as a common soil bacterium that contains a gene which produces a protein harmful pests that destroys eggplant crops.

The plain understanding of the use of GMO is that, it is a process wherein a chemical is used to improve crops. First, we must weigh things in order for us to think whether the courts should interfere with the use of GMO. The advantages of GMO is that it preserves the quality of crops, makes it pest resistant and gives it a better quality. However, GMOs are also found to be dangerous to human health causing cancer and other diseases because it contains a great number of chemicals which may be very harmful to humans. By this analyzations, we may conclude that the court’s interference is necessary to tackle the dispute. The government as the parent of the state, should always be observant and show strict authority to its people. The best interest of the public must always be put into consideration. According to scientists, not all GMOs are harmful to humans, it may be harmful to pests but it doesn’t mean that we also generalize the effect of GMOs to human. Some GMOs have a negative effect on humans but some of them are just ordinary crops that doesn’t give us any harmful effects. The issue on GMO is a serious matter because it may endanger humanity. The court’s decision to put TRO against GMO is correctly made. The long period of use of GMO alarmed our government because of its negative effects. It fears that the GMOs may greatly affect our economy, agriculture and the human being.  Our court should meticulously study about the matter because whenever the court interferes into issues involving our country, its people are obliged to submit to its authority.


There is a saying that “We are what we eat,” if we want to have a longer life span, we should be observant on what we eat. Our government is indeed responsible for the welfare of its people but we in ourselves should be vigilant especially to anything that we consume. GMOs may be beneficially to our country because it assures farmers the good harvest and gives them the opportunity to import their crops and make a good living. However, we should think of the circumstances of whatever actions we make because it may greatly affect our lives.